In a shocking twist, a Wisconsin couple stands accused of orchestrating a sinister poisoning scheme targeting ex-lovers, pushing the limits of personal vendetta into the realm of attempted murder.
At a Glance
- Wisconsin prosecutors charge a couple with attempted murder.
- Accused of attempting to poison two of VanDuyne’s ex-girlfriends.
- Multiple toxic substances allegedly used.
- Seven investigators were hospitalized during the search.
Attempted Murder Charges Filed
Paul VanDuyne Jr. and his girlfriend Andrea Whitaker face serious charges in Wisconsin for allegedly plotting to poison VanDuyne’s former romantic partners. Prosecutors in Rock County and Dane County have accused the pair of targeting two women in an elaborate attempt to settle old scores. The frenzy of attempted poisoning exposed a dangerous cocktail of chemicals VanDuyne and Whitaker are alleged to have conspired to use.
Watch a report: Wisconsin couple conspired to kill man’s ex-girlfriends with cyanide
The aggressive means allegedly considered by the couple included toxic substances like thallium, cyanide, hydrogen sulfide, and homemade abrin. This level of premeditated action underscores the potential lethality of their purported plan. Authorities claim that their actions went beyond planning, including stalking the Rock County victim and inflicting harm. According to reports, they even broke into one victim’s car multiple times to further the scheme.
Young Victim Caught in the Crossfire
In a chilling revelation, the younger sister of one victim in Rock County was also allegedly exposed to harm during one incident. The attempted poisoning spread far beyond its initial targets, illustrating the recklessness at play. This tragic facet of the case amplifies the gravity of their actions, as an innocent minor was unwittingly dragged into the chaos instigated by the couple’s harmful intent.
For their actions in Rock County, VanDuyne and Whitaker face three counts of first-degree attempted murder, further aggravated by charges of aggravated battery, reckless endangerment, and stalking resulting in bodily harm. In Dane County, VanDuyne’s charges include two counts of first-degree attempted murder and stalking. Meanwhile, Whitaker simultaneously faces charges as a party to a crime and for aiding a felon.
Exposure Endangers Agents
The case took a dramatic turn when seven Department of Criminal Investigations agents were hospitalized after being exposed to a hazardous substance while executing search warrants at the couple’s location. This element underscores the real and present danger the couple allegedly posed not just to their intended victims, but also to law enforcement personnel striving to bring them to justice. The investigation has awakened serious concerns about the degree to which personal grievances may lead individuals to employ such extreme and dangerous actions.
